Tuesday, July 15, 2014

Mystery: I'd Tell You I Love You, but then I'd Have to Kill You by Ally Carter




















Carter, A. (2006). I’d tell you I love you, but then I’d have to kill you. New York, NY: Hyperion.  

Plot Summary:  Fifteen-year-old Cammie Morgan is not your average teenager.  She attends the Gallagher Academy for Exceptional Young Women where learning Swahili, Covert Ops, and PhD-level chemistry are all part of the school’s basic curriculum. It’s a spy school and Cammie has been training her whole life to continue her parents' legacy.  Then one day, she falls for a normal boy in town who can never know the truth about her.  Unfortunately, being a normal teenage girl is not something the Gallagher Academy has ever trained her for.

Critical Analysis:  Stacy Hayman from VOYA writes that Carter’s novel, I’d Tell You I love you, But Then I’d Have to Kill You, is “written in an easy-to-read, conversational tone, this novel combines the real (learning how to talk to boys) and the unreal (learning how to be a secret agent for the government) in a strangely believable way” (2006, Children’s Comprehensive Database).  Not only is Carter’s book geared for young adult audiences who love a good spy story, but it’s also full of entertaining spy-related information which keeps the readers engaged throughout the story.  In a Children’s Literature review, Mary Loftus states that there are, “fun spy-related details in the story, which will have most readers chuckling” (2006, Children’s Comprehensive Database).  Carter does a great job in creating an extraordinary spy school for young girls. But, Cammie still has a lot to learn, especially about the one thing the school doesn’t teach – boys.  Claudia Moore from the School Library Journal writes, “By the end of Ally Carter's novel the truth is revealed and Cammie has learned more about herself than she has about spying” (2006, Books in Print).  Ally Carter captures the reader’s interest with the Gallagher Academy for Exceptional Young Women with its historical background, challenging spy courses, and likable characters.  Cammie Morgan grew up with parents who were spies, she goes to an all-girl spy school, and she is training to be a covert operative one day.  While on a mission from her CoveOps teacher, Mr. Soloman, Cammie and her two best friends, Liz and Bex, are separated and Cammie is forced to complete their objective on her own.  The only thing she doesn’t count on is being spotted by a local town boy named Josh.  Suddenly, Cammie’s world is turned upside down by a boy who can never really know who she is or where she goes to school.  But, Cammie can’t get Josh out of her head…or her heart.  

Carter does a great job in developing Cammie Morgan, the perfect teenage spy-in-training who has learned nothing else but spy-related courses, such as advanced martial arts, covert operations training, and learning to speak in fourteen different languages.  She may not be a genius like her friend, Liz, but she can hold her own at the Gallagher’s Academy where her mother is an ex-spy and headmistress of the school.  Cammie may not be the most confident of the Gallagher girls, but she takes pride in being unseen, which is how she earned her spy name, “The Chameleon.”  She knows her stuff and is confident in the beginning of the story that being a spy is where her life is headed.  But, as the story unfolds she comes to realize that there is more to life than just spy school – which turns out to be a normal local boy named Josh.  Cammie’s lack of knowledge when it comes to the opposite sex is revealed when she states, “The boy of my dreams may have been as close as the town of Roseville...but he and I would never speak the same language - which is totally ironic, since “boy” was the one language my school had never tried to teach me” (p.129).  Liz, Bex, and Macey are almost like Cammie’s sidekicks as they help her with spy school missions and gathering intel on Josh.  Although they are an important part of Cammie’s life, there is not too much known about Liz, Bex, and Macey other than a little parental background.  Macey’s character seems to be the most complex of all, yet most of what the reader learns about her are rumors Cammie has heard.  One example is when Cammie mentions that she heard Macey “hijacked a sheik’s yacht in the Mediterranean” (p.190).

The setting of the story takes place mostly at the Gallagher Academy and the town of Roseville.  It is also written in first person through Cammie’s point of view.  So, you don’t know what else is going on in the story unless it’s something Cammie sees or hears. But, the story also includes fun spy-related material that readers will find humorous, such as “the science of Garbology” (p.119), and the different flavors and uses of “Evapopaper” (p.8).  In addition, references to military jargon/lingo are used, such as “17:35 hours (that’s five thirty-five P.M.): The Operative moved into position. 18:00 hours: The Operative was wishing she’d brought something to eat because she couldn’t leave her post to go buy a candy bar, much less use the bathroom” (p.147).  Most readers will enjoy the spy-related humor and the intricate details of the Gallagher Academy, which is complete with sliding mirrors, hidden elevators, and basement classrooms.

Although more chic lit than a mystery novel, readers of I’d Tell You I Love You, But Then I’d Have To Kill You will enjoy Carter’s fresh twist on the idea of an all-girls spy school. Readers who like The Squad: Perfect Cover by Jennifer Barnes and Code Name Cassandra by Meg Cabot will also enjoy this novel.  This book is recommended for readers in grades 6 and up.

References
Hayman, Stacy. (2006, Oct.). Becoming a super spy is not easy. [Review of the book I’d tell you I love you, but then I’d have to kill you, written by Ally Carter]. VOYA. Children’s Comprehensive Database. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:4529/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=0&isbn=9781423100034

Loftus, Mary. (2006). Everyone in the town of Roseville thinks the Gallagher Academy for Exceptional Young Women. [Review of the book I’d tell you I love you, but then I’d have to kill you, written by Ally Carter]. Children’s Literature. Children’s Comprehensive Database. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:4529/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=0&isbn=9781423100034

Moore, Claudia. (2006, Aug. 1). Cammie Morgan attends prestigious Gallagher Academy. [Review of the book I’d tell you I love you, but then I’d have to kill you, written by Ally Carter]. School Library Journal. Books in Print. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:3959/DetailedView.aspx?hreciid=|16076222|31004313&mc=USA#

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Utopia/Dystopia: Matched by Ally Condie




















Condie, A. (2010). Matched. New York, NY: Scholastic Inc.     
              
Plot Summary:  Seventeen year-old Cassia Reyes lives in a world where the Society knows and decides everything for everyone.  They decide who you will marry, where you will work, and even when you will die.  But, when Cassia sees two boys as her “Match” for marriage her faith in the system starts to falter.  Although the Officials assure Cassia that her best friend Xander, is the correct match, she cannot get the second boy, Ky, out of her head.   In a world where free will is not an option, Cassie has to make the biggest choice of all. Will she follow the laws of the system and lead the life that has been chosen for her, or will she break the rules to follow her own heart?

Critical Analysis:  Heidi Hauser Green from Children’s Literaturestates that in Matched by Ally Condie, “Cassia is a believable, complex, poetic character and her struggles for understanding and justice ring true” (2010, Children’s Comprehensive Database).  Anthony Doyle from the School Library Journal also correlates Green’s comments when he states that Cassia’s “awakening and development are realistically portrayed, and supporting characters like Cassia's parents and her grandfather add depth to the story” (2010, Books in Print). In addition to realistic characters, Condie also develops and portrays the “utopian” world where Cassia lives in perfect and disturbing detail.  Courtney Jones from Booklist states that Condie “easily tears this world apart while deftly exploring the individual cost of societal perfection and the sacrifices inherent in freedom of choice” (2010, Children’s Comprehensive Database).  Ally Condie not only creates a perfect world where everything is decided for you, but she also creates the perfect storm where nothing is what it seems or lasts forever.  In Matched, Cassia Reyes thinks her world is perfect.  There are no diseases, food is prepared for you by your unique nutrition requirements, there is practically no crime, you are given work assignments based on your talents, and you are systematically “matched” to the perfect mate.  But, when Cassia is matched to more than one boy, she starts to question how “perfect” the Society really is and how many other times they’ve made mistakes.  Soon, Cassia starts to question everything and wants a life that she chooses, not one that is chosen for her.  Disobedience and rebellion are not tolerated in the Society and they are keeping close tabs on Cassia and her family.  When Cassia finally thinks she’s unlocked the secrets to how the Society really works, she soon realizes that her world is a lot more complicated and cruel than she originally thought.

Condie’s development of the Society in Matched is ingeniously crafted.  Although, eerily similar to The Giver by Lois Lowry, Condie’s story is still unique and stands on its own merit.  As the story unfolds, so does the world of Matched. You learn about the “emotion” pills, the school system, the Officials who enforce and monitor everything, the matching system, and the age at which a citizen is chosen to die.  In addition, one of the elements that still rings true of many Utopian/Dystopian societies is the brainwashing of its citizens.  This is evident when Cassia says, “there’s no reason to rebel.  Look at what the Society gives us. Good lives.  A chance at immortality. The only way it can be ruined is if we ruin it ourselves” (p. 136). The concept of “big brother” is evident throughout the story as well and is at the heart of what keeps the citizens in check.  The fear of getting an “infraction” and being labeled as an “Abberration” is something no good citizen wants – it only makes your quality of life more difficult.  You cannot be matched with someone and your work assignment is the worst.  The reader will come to realize that this is how the Officials control the citizens and one of the main reasons the Society functions without too many disturbances. 
  
The character development of Cassia over the course of the story is very well done.  In the beginning, you can see how she sees the rules of the Society make sense to her and everyone else.  She doesn’t like to break the rules and is happy with the way her life is – it is all she has ever known.  But, at her grandfather’s “Final Banquet” he reveals to her an illegal poem that provokes to her to “not be gentle” and to fight for what she believes in.  Soon, Cassia starts to question and wonder about the way her world works.  This, coupled with the mistake of the second boy appearing as her match, gets Cassia questioning.  Eventually, she realizes that the Society is not perfect after all and their control over its citizens is disturbingly wrong.   This is evident when she says, “I feel disgust when I think of how we climb our little hills when the Officials say the word. How we hand over our most precious items at their bidding.  How we never, ever fight” (p. 210).  Ky’s development is a little less direct than Cassia’s since the story is told through her point of view.  But, Condie expertly crafts Ky’s backstory as drawings he gives to Cassia that show her a glimpse of his past. Both Cassia and the reader little by little about what happened to Ky and his parents before he moved in with his aunt and uncle. For example, in one scene Cassia is looking at a drawing Ky gave her and says, “In the middle of the crease Ky drew a village, little houses, little people.  But all the people lie prone, on their backs. No one stands straight, except the two Kys. The young one’s hands are no longer empty; they carry something. One hand holds the world Mother, slumping over the edge of his hand, shaped a little like a body” (p. 222).  It’s not until much later in the story that you find out the heartbreaking truth of how Ky became an orphan.  The relationship that Cassia has with her grandfather has a lasting impact on her throughout the story.  It is his character that gives her the strength to “not go gentle” when it comes to fighting for her own choices and future.

Matchedby Ally Condie is a story about love, breaking societal barriers, and finding your own path. This novel is highly recommended for 6th grade and up.  Readers of Divergent by Veronica Roth, The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, and The Giver by Lois Lowry will enjoy this thought-provoking story.


References

Doyle, Anthony. (2010, Dec. 1). In a story that is at once evocative of Lois Lowry's The Giver. [Review of the book Matched, written by Ally Condie.] School Library Journal. Books in Print. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:3959/DetailedView.aspx?hreciid=|30738161|35063347&mc=USA#

Green, Heidi H. (2010). Seventeen-year old Cassie has reached an important milestone. [Review of the book Matched, written by Ally Condie.] Children’s Literature. Children’s Comprehensive Database. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:4529/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=1&isbn=9780525423645

Jones, Courtney. (2010, Sept. 15). Do not go gentle into that good night. [Review of the book Matched, written by Ally Condie.] Booklist, Vol. 107: No. 2. Children’s Comprehensive Database.Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:4529/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=1&isbn=9780525423645

Tuesday, July 1, 2014

Contemporary Realistic Fiction: Anna and the French Kiss by Stephanie Perkins




















Perkins, Stephanie. (2010). Anna and the French Kiss. New York, NY: Dutton Books.     

Plot Summary: Forced to spend her senior year in Paris, France at an American boarding school, Anna Oliphant is scared to even leave her own dorm room.  But, with the help of her classmates Meredith, Rashmi, Josh, and St. Clair the “City of Light” begins to grow on her.  And so does her new beautiful and charming friend Etienne St. Clair.  The only problem is he has a serious girlfriend and Anna has her own new crush on a boy back home in Atlanta. Anna’s last year in high school just got a little more complicated. 

Critical Analysis:
A review from Shelle Rosenfeld from Booklist described the novel as having “vivid descriptions of Parisian culture and places, and a cast of diverse, multifaceted characters, including adults, this lively title incorporates plenty of issues that will resonate with teens, from mean girls to the quest for confidence and the complexities of relationships in all their forms” (2010, Children’s Comprehensive Database).  A Kirkusreview stated that “Perkins's debut surpasses the usual chick-lit fare with smart dialogue, fresh characters and plenty of tingly interactions, all set amid pastries, parks and walks along the Seine in arguably the most romantic city in the world” (2010, Children’s Comprehensive Database).  In Anna and the French Kiss, Perkins delivers a romantic teen novel that brings to life the Parisian culture, charming characters, and effortless humor. High school senior Anna Oliphant is forced by her parents to live in Paris, France at an American boarding school.  Although left on her own, Anna is instantly welcomed by her dorm neighbor Meredith and introduces her to her own circle of friends Rashmi, Josh, and Étienne St. Clair.  Insecure, yet determined to survive Paris, Anna comes to love the Parisian culture and her new friends, especially the charming and handsome St. Clair. Unfortunately for Anna, St. Clair has a serious girlfriend named Elle who just graduated and Anna has her own crush named Toph back home in Atlanta.  Anna’s stay in Paris is a little less stressful because her dream of becoming a movie critic is helped by the ample amounts of cinemas all over Paris, especially down the street from her own dorm room. Although St. Clair has a girlfriend, Anna finds herself spending more and more time with him and he doesn’t seem to mind at all.  This leads to a lot of misunderstandings and confusion on Anna’s part because her feelings for him are growing and she thinks he may be feeling the same way.   However, St. Clair has not broken up with his girlfriend even though he and Anna have become close and this leaves Anna hurt and confused.  To feel better, she ends up dating another student named Dave but that doesn’t end well and she focuses her thoughts on Toph back in Atlanta.  Everything changes when Anna goes home for Christmas break and finds out that Toph is now dating her best friend Bridge.  Devastated, Anna keeps in communication with St. Clair who has become her best friend and is trying to keep his spirits up since learning that his mother has cancer. Readers will fall in love with Anna and St. Clair and root for their match-up throughout the story.

The setting of the story is in the heart of beautiful Paris, France.  Perkins takes the reader to many different historical sites such as the Eiffel tower, Notre-Dame, and even the pantheon, where it’s described as an “unimaginable number of domes and columns and arches. Everything is huge and round. Enormous frescoes of saints, warriors, and angels are painted across the walls” (p. 168).  Not only are you whisked away to this beautiful “city of light,” but you are also introduced to many of its wonderful food.  On one occasion, Anna and Meredith stop at a cake shop where the front case “shimmers with neat rows of square-shaped tarte citrons, spongy cakes swelling with molten chocolate, caramel éclairs like ballet slippers, and fruity cakes with wild strawberries dusted in powdery sugar” (p.158).  American readers who are unfamiliar with Paris, will be educated with more of its unique differences, such as calling soccer “football” and that “Restaurant dinners are measured in hours, not minutes” (p.157) – like American fast-food restaurant chains.  Readers will get an insight to Paris living through the eyes of Anna and perhaps appreciate the Parisian culture along the way.

The character development of the story is appealing and authentic to modern teen romance.  Anna is insecure, yet charming and funny and will win the readers vote for a happy ending.  She is not only likable; she is also relatable and many teen readers will identify with the inner thoughts of Anna as she interacts with St. Clair.   In one scene, Anna is at the cinema with her friends when, “St. Clair coughs and shifts again.  His leg brushes against mine.  It stays there. I’m paralyzed. I should move it; it feels too unnatural. How can he not notice his leg is touching my leg?  There. He glanced at me. I know he did” (p.106).  Étienne St. Clair, most often referred to as just “St. Clair,” is the handsome boy-next-door who was born in San Francisco but raised in London, which is where he developed his charming English accent.  Although he has a long-time girlfriend named Elle, St. Clair is struggling to figure out his own feeling towards his new friend Anna.  St. Clair’s lack of initiative to break up with Elle leaves Anna confused and hurt, but she is determined to at least remain friends with a boy she has come to love.  The friendship and romance between Elle and St. Clair is heartfelt, genuine, and leaves the reader thoroughly content when they come together in the end.  The romance between Anna and St. Clair is natural and completely believable as it develops slowly throughout the course of the book.  Meredith, Rashmi, and Josh are side characters that add dimension to the story by allowing the reader to understand the sometimes confusing actions of St. Clair since the story is only told through Anna’s point of view. For example, after a night out drinking Anna finally thinks St. Clair is ready to move on from Elle because she knows how unhappy he is. However, it doesn’t happen and it’s up to Rashmi to fill her in later about what Josh told her regarding St. Clair’s state of mind.  For example, Rashmi tells Anna, “Josh says with all this stuff with his mom, he’s (St. Clair) been too freaked out to change anything else in his life” (p. 281).  

Anna and the French Kiss will appeal to readers of chic-lit who love a genuine teen romance.  It’s filled with delicious food, beautiful scenery, and laugh-out loud humor.  This book is recommended for young adults and above.




References

Kirkus Reviews. (2010, Nov. 1). Since her father’s Nicholas Sparks-like novels have been turned into blockbuster movies [Review of the book Anna and the French Kiss, written by Stephanie Perkins]. Kirkus, Vol. 78: No. 21. Children’s Comprehensive Database. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:4529/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=1&isbn=9780525423270

Rosenfeld, Shelle. (2010, Nov.15). Anna is not happy about spending senior year at a Paris boarding school [Review of the book Anna and the French Kiss, written by Stephanie Perkins]. Booklist, Vol. 7: No. 6. Children’s Comprehensive Database. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.twu.edu:4529/index.php/jbookdetail/jqbookdetail?page=1&pos=1&isbn=9780525423270